The Hole Truth: 2 Bagel Recipes Worth Waking Up For

At first glance, a bagel might seem like a humble ring of dough, but look beyond its simplicity and a rich story emerges of a culinary tradition that’s been passed across continents and generations.

Originating in Jewish communities in Poland, the bagel owes its signature chew to a clever workaround: boiling the dough before baking. Anti-Semitic laws at the time barred Jewish bakers from making “bread,” but boiled dough didn’t qualify.

By boiling first, Jewish bakers sidestepped the restriction and, in the process, created the chewy texture that defines the bagel to this day. The hole served a purpose, too: it ensured that the dough cooked evenly during boiling. A loophole in more ways than one.

When Eastern European immigrants arrived in North America in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, the bagel came with them. By the mid-1900s, New York and Montreal had transformed it into a cultural icon, each with its own unique expression.

New York bagels are large and satisfyingly chewy, with a smaller hole that maximizes schmear real estate, while Montreal bagels are sweeter (thanks to honey-infused boiling water), wood-fired, crisp-edged, and often paired with the city’s legendary smoked meat.

What makes the perfect bagel depends on who you ask. Some swear by an assertive chew; others want a crackling crust and dense crumb. Even a plain bagel should carry depth – a hint of malt, a touch of sweetness, a flavor that stands confidently on its own before any topping ever touches it.

Above all, a great bagel is fresh. Warm from the bakery, it needs little more than a swipe of butter or cream cheese to feel complete. Toasting can revive a day-old bagel, but nothing rivals the ritual pleasure of eating one at its peak.

Now that we’ve covered the foundations, here are three recipes that’ll elevate your bagel experience from the familiar to the unexpected.

---

The East-Meets-West BEC

In New York City, a “classic breakfast bagel” boils down to three essentials: bacon, egg and cheese. Here, we honor that iconic BEC trio while slipping in a subtle Asian twist – just enough to add some kick without straying from its deli-counter soul.

The familiar comfort of melty cheese and crispy bacon meets a hint of spice and umami, creating a fusion that feels both fresh and faithful to tradition. It’s the kind of mash-up that makes you wonder why it wasn’t on the menu all along.

INGREDIENTS:

• 1 sesame or everything bagel, sliced and toasted
• 1-2 eggs, cooked your way (we’d recommend scrambled)
• 2 slices bacon
• 1-2 slices American cheddar cheese
• 3 tbsp cream cheese
• 1 tbsp finely sliced scallions
• 1 tsp chili crisp
• Fresh cracked pepper (optional)

INSTRUCTIONS:

1. In a small bowl, mix the cream cheese with the scallions until evenly combined and fragrant.
2. Fry bacon until crisp, then set aside to drain on paper towels.
3. Cook the egg to your preference, though a soft, semi-runny yolk is usually the goal.
4. Spread the scallion cream cheese generously over both toasted bagel halves.
5. Drizzle chili crisp over the cream cheese.
6. Add the cheddar, then the hot egg on top so the cheese begins to soften, followed by the bacon, then freshly cracked black pepper if using.
7. Close the sandwich and bite in while everything’s hot.

---

The Gourmet Schmear: Smoked Salmon with Horseradish Herb Labneh

A refined riff on the classic salmon bagel, this version takes things up a notch by elevating the schmear – the Yiddish term for a creamy bagel spread – with fresh herbs and a touch of fiery horseradish, then finished with briny pops of salmon roe and capers.

The combination brings a lively contrast of textures and flavors: silky salmon, cool tangy labneh, herbal freshness and little bursts of salt from the roe. It’s elegant enough for a brunch gathering but simple enough to assemble on a weekday, offering a fresh, modern take on a beloved deli staple.

INGREDIENTS:

• 1 plain or poppy-seed bagel, sliced in half and lightly toasted
• ⅓ cup labneh or thick Greek yogurt
• ½ tsp creamy horseradish (to taste; start small, then add more if more heat is desired)
• Zest of ½ lemon
• 1 tbsp finely snipped chives
• 3-4 slices smoked salmon
• Thinly sliced Persian cucumbers
• Pickled red onions
• 1-2 tsp capers
• 1 tbsp salmon roe (ikura)
• Freshly cracked black pepper
• Optional: drizzle of good olive oil

INSTRUCTIONS:

1. Make the schmear by combining the labneh, horseradish, lemon zest, and chives in a food processor or blender. Blend until smooth and airy.
2. Generously spread the mixture over both toasted bagel halves.
3. Add layers of smoked salmon, followed by cucumber slices, pickled red onion, and a scattering of capers.
4. Finish by spooning salmon roe over the top and crack fresh pepper to taste.
5. For an optional flourish, drizzle with a little infused olive oil – lemon or Tuscan herb works beautifully.
6. Present open-faced for maximum visual impact.

Make your next bagel – and the rituals around it – more memorable with BOMSHBEE’s thoughtful table designs and homeware.